Should You Go for a Jack of All Trades or an Industry Expert?

Among your crucial roles as a new business leader is choosing and hiring the right staff members to help your company grow. Without the right people to do the job, your startup would cease to exist.

These individuals will not only take part in day-to-day business operations efficiently, but they will likewise act as the face of your company, which is why it’s crucial to take some time to find and hire the right people for your business. They need to aspire with you and realize your company’s vision with you. They need to grow the business and focus on what your company’s objectives are. See, the right team members can help any startup to go far and grow beyond imagination.

So will you go with a jack of all trades or hire a specialist to help you out? Indeed, there will always be a different platform for specialists. Surely, if you are one of the many individuals looking for a divorce attorney, you want to be represented by someone whose specialty is divorce. However, generalists are called jack of all trades for a reason; they can do more things than what is expected of them.

This write-up is not about pitting specialists against generalists but understanding your business needs and finding the right talent to do the job.

Which is better for your business needs?

As you seek to expand your team, should you hire generalists or specialists? It relies on your objectives. Generalists are individuals who have particular skills but are versatile to continue learning and mastering more.

These jacks-of-all-trades can change gears promptly and conveniently. They can drive manual cars, automatic cars, and even the newest Tesla without problems. Employing generalists will provide your organization with an array of arsenal to stay versatile in an ever-transforming world of businesses. These talents can cover even more bases with fewer employees.

Generalists are eager people; they are voraciously hungry for more. They tend to learn, adapt, and apply everything that they come across. For example, an admin officer working closely with your accounting team and your HR team will be able to perform the essential functions needed by the two departments, from simply attendance and compliance checking to collaborate with the accounting team with the information for faster processing.

What better way to nurture a generalist but give them many things to do? The person can be your assistant, your right-hand man, and even your trusted manager. Who knows?

When to employ specialists

However, as the business expands, you can now transition from broad skills to specific ones by employing specialists. Specialists can take a company, specifically an expanding one, to the next level by constructively pointing out where you need to improve. They will know tactical and critical aspects of your business that you need to change or remove, further developing competitive advantages for your business.

Generalists know less than specialists in terms of knowledge depth, but they know more (different) things. There are benefits and trade-offs to both. A generalist can successfully deal with numerous tasks but will likely be ruled out by a specialist. On the other hand, experts understand everything about their specialization, yet they might not be comfortable trying out new things or learning from different perspectives. They tend to stay on their track and improve their sole skills.


Your particular needs are going to differ based upon your organization. However, generalizing experts and also specialized professionals will do nothing good. If you feel like generalists are less valuable than specialists, that is not true. Additionally, if you feel like a specialist is just an old dog who cannot perform new tricks. The trick is finding candidates with the possibility to turn into those roles and training them based on your business’ needs. As an example, employing generalists and also nurturing them to come to be specialists. Or giving generalist roles that they are good at and partnering them with a specialist consultant.

As a business leader, you also should not capitalize on professionals that can do many things. They are talented innovators, and they should also be compensated justly.

Being called a jack of all trades should not have a negative connotation. People usually say, “Jack of all trades, master of none.” That is not true. These talents can work wonders for your business and organization if you know where to place them. These people are jack of all trades for a reason, and if you have them work closely with a team of specialists, the possibilities of innovation and growth will be endless.




About the Author:

Sign Up
For Newsletter

Hottest articles on your inbox!
Scroll to Top